Cincinnati Financial Corporation Tax-Qualified Savings Plan
Cincinnati Financial Corporation · Fairfield, OH · EIN 310746871 · Plan 002 · Form 5500 for plan year 2024
What Cincinnati Financial put into the plan, per active participant
$5,133
Cincinnati Financial Corporation put $5,133 into this plan for each of its 5,564 active participants in plan year 2024. That is the whole employer side, matching money, profit sharing, non-elective and safe-harbor contributions and reallocated forfeitures together, because the Form 5500 reports them on one line, so it is not the match rate.
Cincinnati Financial put in more per active participant than 51% of plans with 5,000+ participants in insurance. The middle plan in that group of 98 reported $5,049. Insurance comes from business code 524150, which Cincinnati Financial Corporation entered on its own Form 5500. Sponsors pick that code themselves, so a code that does not describe what the employer does ranks the plan against the wrong companies.
What this figure cannot separate: how much Cincinnati Financial pays, and how much it puts in
This is dollars, not a rate. A Form 5500 carries no payroll, so the figure reflects both how much the employer puts in and how much the employer pays: two plans running the same formula report different amounts when one pays better. Crossing the peer group with industry holds most of that difference still, and none of it disappears.
This is one plan year, not an average. A true-up, a plan merger or a one-off contribution moves a single year on its own.
Source: Form 5500 filing for the plan year ended December 31, 2024, received by the DOL June 20, 2025 · DOL EFAST2 ↗
The $5,133 above is the Form 5500 figure for plan year 2024, and it counts every employer dollar on one line. Cincinnati Financial Corporation also files a Form 11-K, which states the match formula on its own for plan year 2025: the section below reads $2,970 a year at a $49,500 salary, and the same filing states employer contributions made outside the match. That second figure is what the formula pays one worker on that salary, and not an amount either filing reports. The two figures cover different plan years and measure different things, so neither one is the other one corrected.
What the plan cost, per participant
$101.62
The plan paid $101.62 per participant in plan-paid administrative expenses in plan year 2024, more expensive than 84% of plans with 5,000+ participants. The middle plan of that size paid $54.84.
Why a plan this big pays less per person before anything else
Bigger plans pay less per head by construction, because the same negotiated bill divides across more people. That is why this ranking sits inside the plan's own size cohort and is never taken across all plans.
Schedule H reports only what came out of plan assets. Fees the sponsor pays directly, and fees taken inside fund expense ratios, never appear here, so this is a floor and not the all-in cost.
401(k) Monitor Score
40 out of 100
Where this plan stands against plans of its size and industry on two amounts its Form 5500 reports: employer money in per active person, and plan-paid cost per person. It reads no match formula, no vesting schedule and no fund lineup, because a Form 5500 states none of them.
- What the employer put in, per active participant: $5,133. Higher than 51% of plans with 5,000+ participants in insurance.
- What the plan cost, per participant: $102. Cheaper than 17% of plans with 5,000+ participants.
On this page: the match and vesting terms · what to check next · every figure on the filing · fees itemised · the plans this one is ranked against · service providers
The match and vesting terms, from a Form 11-K
The match formula and the vesting schedule are stated in a Form 11-K, which is filed only by employers whose plan holds company stock. A Form 5500 reports neither.
What Cincinnati Financial puts in
$2,970
a year, at a $49,500 salary.
The match paragraph, word for word
“Participants are eligible for a Company match of 100% up to the first 6% of eligible compensation on a per-pay-period basis; however, those participants who accrue benefits under the Cincinnati Financial Corporation Retirement Plan are not eligible for the Company match.”
What you contribute to collect all of it
Contribute at least 6% of your pay to collect the full match.
That is $2,970 a year at a $49,500 salary, and it scales with your own.
Vesting score
57.14 out of 100
How fast the employer’s money becomes yours. Higher than 4% of the 253 schedules we have scored.
It measures vesting speed and nothing else. It says nothing about the size of the match, what the plan charges, or the funds inside it.
Share of the employer's money that is the worker's at hire and at each of the first 6 anniversaries: 0%, 0%, 0%, 100%, 100%, 100%, 100%. The score is the average of those 7 readings.
Vesting, word for word
“Participants are vested immediately in their contributions plus actual earnings thereon and vested in any Company matching contribution and profit-sharing contribution attributed to them plus actual earnings thereon after three years of eligible service. Unvested participants who are employed by the Company become fully vested in any Company and profit-sharing contribution attributed to them upon reaching age 65 or as defined in the plan.”
The plan tops the match up after year end, so contributing unevenly through the year does not cost the worker part of it.
The same match paragraph, word for word
“Participants are eligible for a Company match of 100% up to the first 6% of eligible compensation on a per-pay-period basis; however, those participants who accrue benefits under the Cincinnati Financial Corporation Retirement Plan are not eligible for the Company match.”
The wait before the match starts and the year-end true-up appear above when the filing states them. Neither is part of the score, and a filing that is silent on one of them is not a plan without it.
What the plan costs, against plans of its size
84th percentile
$101.62 per participant in plan-paid administrative cost, more expensive than 84% of plans with 5,000+ participants.
The match, vesting and eligibility terms above are read from the Form 11-K filed by Cincinnati Financial Corporation, whose page states the full formula, the vesting schedule and the sentence behind each one.
What to check next
Collecting the whole match
Cincinnati Financial’s Form 11-K pays the whole match at 6% of pay, which is $2,970 a year at a $49,500 salary and scales with your own. Your payslip and your Fidelity NetBenefits ↗ account both show the rate you set. A rate below 6% collects less than the whole match.
That Form 11-K covers plan year 2025. The plan’s Summary Plan Description states the terms in force, and the plan administrator must provide it to participants on request.
What to ask about the fees
This plan paid $101.62 per participant out of plan assets, more than 84% of plans with 5,000+ participants, where the middle plan paid $54.84. The filing does not say what the difference buys. Two questions put that to a benefits or HR team: what the recordkeeping and administration contract costs, and how much of it comes out of participant accounts rather than being paid by Cincinnati Financial. The lines this total is made of are further down.
Your own numbers are not on this page
Every figure here is the whole plan for plan year 2024, taken from one filing and divided by headcounts. Your own contribution rate, your balance and the fees taken from your account are on your recordkeeper’s site, which this filing names as Fidelity NetBenefits ↗. What you may put in during a year is set by the IRS and not by the plan: this year’s limits ↗.
Key figures
| Total plan assets, end of year | $1,286,419,450 |
|---|---|
| Net assets | $1,286,419,450 |
| Participants, beginning of year | 6,242 |
| Of which active | 5,564 |
| Plan type | Single employer |
| Size cohortThe peer group we rank fees against. | 5,000+ participants |
| Employer share of the money that went in, plan year 2024The rest came from employees, who put in $53,988,646. The share falls when employees save more, so a plan whose staff contribute heavily reads lower here through no act of the employer. It is printed as a fact and it is not part of the score. | 35% |
Plan-paid administrative expenses
The plan paid $634,301 in administrative expenses in plan year 2024, across 6,242 participants: $101.62 per participant.
| Contract administrator fees | $9,000 |
|---|---|
| Professional fees | not reported in filing |
| Investment management fees | $286,767 |
| Other administrative fees | $0 |
These are plan-paid expenses from Schedule H only. Fees the sponsor pays directly, and fees embedded in fund expense ratios, never appear here. This figure is a floor, not the all-in cost, and a low number is not “free”.
The plans this one is ranked against
Fees on this page are ranked against the 5,000+ participant cohort, where the median plan pays $54.84 per participant. The sponsor files from Ohio, one of 2,465 plans on file there, at a median of $134.01 per participant. Its business code places the plan in insurance, one of 1,068 on file, which run to a median of $119.27.
Plans of a similar size in Ohio
| Plan | Participants | Cost per participant |
|---|---|---|
| Advanced Drainage Systems, Inc. Retirement And Stock Ownership PlanAdvanced Drainage Systems, Inc. | 6,715 | $97.56 |
| Applied Industrial Technologies, Inc. Retirement Savings PlanApplied Industrial Technologies, Inc. | 6,299 | $98.65 |
| Multi-Color 401(k) Savings PlanMulti-Color Corporation | 6,172 | $78.40 |
| Dayton Freight Lines, Inc. Employee 401(k) Retirement PlanDayton Freight Lines, Inc. | 6,013 | $58.80 |
Service providers (Schedule C)
Recordkeeper: Fidelity Investments (as filed: “FIDELITY INVESTMENTS INSTITUTIONAL”)
10,593 plans on file name Fidelity Investments as their recordkeeper, at a median of $97.71 per participant.
| Provider | Service codes | Direct comp. ($) | Indirect comp. ($) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fidelity Investments Institutional | 71, 64, 60, 37, 65, 25 | 311,459 | 0 |
| Strategic Advisors, Inc. | 27 | 286,767 | not reported |
| Deloitte & Touche LLP | 10 | 53,000 | not reported |
| Keating Muething & Klekamp Pll | 29, 16 | 10,045 | not reported |
Useful links
- Find a 401(k) you left at an old job ↗
The DOL's Retirement Savings Lost & Found. Free and official.
- Look up this plan's full Form 5500 ↗
The DOL's own filing search. Search by plan or sponsor name.
- Download this plan's data (CSV) ↗
Every field on this page, one row, ready for a spreadsheet.
Source
| Dataset | DOL EFAST2 Form 5500 bulk data (FOIA) |
|---|---|
| Form year | 2024 |
| Filing ACK_ID | 20250620104634NAL0002291347001 |
| Dataset last refreshed | July 28, 2026 |
Bulk dataset at askebsa.dol.gov ↗ · Look up the filing on EFAST2 ↗
Filings lag by design: a plan can file up to 9½ months after its year ends, so this is the newest data on file. Why filings lag
Cite this page
401(k) Monitor, "Cincinnati Financial Corporation Tax-Qualified Savings Plan: Form 5500 facts", from DOL EFAST2 filing 20250620104634NAL0002291347001, plan year ended December 31, 2024. 401(k) Monitor Score 40 out of 100 (exact value 40.3).